Miami Judge Abby Cynamon Sees Through Fabiola Carisimo’s Scheme: The Truth Behind Miami’s Marriage Fraud
Miami has seen plenty of immigration controversies, but none quite as ridiculous as the case of Fabiola Carisimo and Julimir Marrero. What started as a poorly planned marriage fraud quickly unraveled into a comedy of errors so blatant that it almost feels intentional.
From a two-week marriage to an unnotarized, mistake-riddled note, to a desperate attempt to exploit the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) by falsely claiming abuse, this saga serves as a glaring example of how not to game the U.S. immigration system.
This so-called marriage lasted barely two weeks on paper, revealing a laughably amateurish attempt to cheat the system.
On October 28, 2024, Judge Cynamon, a prominent judge serving in Florida’s 11th Judicial Circuit Court, made it clear that she isn’t tolerating Fabiola’s nonsense anymore and would not grant her a divorce.
A Quick “Marriage” and a Swift Separation
Fabiola Carisimo, an Argentine immigrant and Julimir Marrero got married on July 24, 2023. Just two weeks later, on August 8, 2023, they separated. A source close to her revealed that Julimir never even moved into their supposed marital home. Fabiola paid Julimir $20,000 for the sham marriage to help with her immigration, but when he tried to renegotiate for more money, she cut him off and then concocted an elaborate story of unreported domestic violence to distance herself from him.
The Purpose Behind This Fraud
The goal of this fake marriage was crystal clear: to get immigration benefits. Everything about their relationship was rushed and hollow, clearly a scheme to manipulate the system. Julimir seemed to have fallen off the face of the planet. Repeated attempts to serve him with court papers failed. But Fabiola surprisingly presented an unnotarized handwritten note from Julimir on March 19, 2024.
Fabiola Has Been in an Eight Year Relationship
A source close to Fabiola shared more details that make things clearer: Fabiola has had a boyfriend in Argentina for eight years who was supporting her financially and even bought her mother a house. According to a source, her boyfriend broke up with her in the last few months for unknown reasons, however her mother is still waiting for the keys.
Julimir Marrero’s Troubled Past
Julimir Marrero has a troubling history that sheds light on his involvement in this fraudulent scheme. Two years before his sham marriage with Fabiola, Julimir was accused of stalking and dating violence involving another woman. These accusations reveal a pattern of problematic behavior, suggesting that Julimir has a history of manipulation and abusive actions. This context helps explain how he found himself entangled in such a dishonest arrangement with Fabiola.
Inconsistent Details Show How Little They Knew Each Other
Another glaring issue is that the details about Julimir physical appearance don’t match across different cases. In an unrelated case filed several years ago, Julimir’s height was described as 6 feet. Fabiola describes his height as 5’8″. Has she ever met the man?
Fabiola Carisimo’s Claims of “Being Protected”
Fabiola has often claimed she is “protected” by powerful connections, hinting at ties to organized crime. However, not everyone is convinced of her competence. One associate sarcastically remarked in Spanish: “Si ella está involucrada, entonces no puede estar organizado.” Translation: “If she’s involved, then it can’t be organized.”
Her actions support this view. The rushed timeline, lack of preparation, and inconsistent details make it clear that this was less of a calculated scheme and more of a desperate gamble.
Fabiola Carisimo’s Professional Background
Professional Facade, Questionable Ethics
Fabiola works as a real estate agent at Avanti Way Realty, serving Miami’s bustling market. Her Instagram account, @FabiolaCarisimo, is a curated mix of glamorous photos and social connections. Beneath the polished surface, however, lies evidence of a network that likely facilitates fraudulent immigration marriages. These scams, though quietly arranged, often involve friends or acquaintances looking for quick cash.
Miami’s Bigger Problem with Fraudulent Marriages
The Carisimo-Marrero debacle isn’t an isolated case. Miami has long been a hotbed for immigration scams, thanks to its large immigrant community and relatively lax oversight. Sham marriages are seen as low-risk, high-reward schemes—at least until they unravel. A marriage lasting two weeks, followed by the partner’s disappearance, raises immediate red flags. Throw in a long-term boyfriend and a poorly written note, and the fraud becomes laughable.
What’s Next for Fabiola?
If prosecuted, Fabiola faces serious consequences, including potential deportation, hefty fines, and a criminal record. While imprisonment is less common in these cases, it’s not off the table—especially under the current administration’s tough stance on immigration enforcement.
With high-profile leaders like Thomas Homan and Stephen Miller doubling down on fraud cases, Fabiola’s actions could serve as an example of what happens when you try to outsmart the system and fail spectacularly.
A Lesson in Hubris
Fabiola Carisimo’s story is a cautionary tale of arrogance and incompetence. Her belief that she could cheat the system without facing consequences is as audacious as it is misguided. For Miami’s Argentine immigration community, it’s yet another reminder that fraud isn’t just unethical—it’s also incredibly risky, and invoking domestic violence insults every woman who has genuinely suffered from its devastating impact.
If you’ve already started your own “Fabiola Fraud”, you still have time to correct it. Smart people learn from the mistakes of others—don’t repeat them. There’s no success in shortcuts as poorly thought out as this. Be smarter, aim higher, and make choices that truly lead to something better, and never underestimate the swift power of American justice.
